Payroll ROI Calculator: Staffing Cost Savings
Compare two staffing options to see what you could save each year and what the change would cost in year one.
Staffing costs
Staffing cost comparison
Example inputs- $6,466
- $104,262
- $97,796
- $64
- $69
- -$954
Annual recurring costs
Put Both Staffing Options on the Same Basis
Use a full year of gross pay or staffing charges for each option. Add employer on-costs, such as super and workers’ compensation premiums, where they apply. Count each cost once if it already appears in the salary package or provider quote.
Keep paid annual leave in annual pay and paid hours. Subtract those leave hours when working out how much time is available for the same work. Use the same definition of productive time for both options, including how you treat time spent on internal admin.
Use the pay rates and entitlements that apply to each arrangement. Fair Work explains how to find the right pay rate and how to pay annual leave. The Australian Taxation Office explains when employer super applies.
Include Supervision and Transition Costs
Multiply each option’s annual supervision hours by the internal cost of an hour of the supervisor’s time. Add that to pay and on-costs to get each option’s annual recurring cost. If the proposed arrangement needs more oversight, that extra time reduces the annual saving.
Enter recruitment, initial training and handover as one-off transition costs. Subtract them from the annual recurring saving to get first-year net savings. If the switch takes place partway through the year, the saving for that calendar year will reflect the shorter period.
Compare Savings With the Work Required
In the starting example, a fictional brokerage considers a staffing change for its loan processing work. The proposal needs 182 hours of annual supervision instead of 104. At $78 an hour, that extra time costs $6,084 a year and reduces the saving from lower pay and on-costs.
| Annual figures | Current | Proposed |
|---|---|---|
| Pay or charges | $84,500 | $73,320 |
| Employer on-costs | $11,650 | $10,280 |
| Supervision cost | $8,112 | $14,196 |
| Recurring cost | $104,262 | $97,796 |
| Paid hours | 1,976 | 1,716 |
| Non-productive hours | 336 | 296 |
| Productive hours | 1,640 | 1,420 |
| Cost per productive hour | $64 | $69 |
Annual recurring savings are $6,466. After the $7,420 transition cost, first-year net savings are -$954, so switching costs $954 more in year one.
Subtract non-productive hours from paid hours, then divide the recurring cost by the remaining hours. The proposed option costs less per year and gives the brokerage 220 fewer hours. Each of those hours costs $69, up from $64.
Check whether the smaller allocation can still cover application volumes and turnaround times.