Broker guide
Notifiable Data Breach: Assess a Brokerage Incident
Does a client-file incident require notification? Work through the Australian breach assessment, remedial action and who your brokerage must notify.
- Published
- Updated
A notifiable data breach can result from unauthorised access to or disclosure of information your brokerage holds and must protect under the scheme. Loss of that information can also qualify if unauthorised access or disclosure is likely. In either case, a reasonable person must find that the access or disclosure is likely to seriously harm at least one individual whose information is involved.
If you have reasonable grounds to believe an eligible breach occurred, notify the Office of the Australian Information Commissioner (OAIC) and notify individuals as required. Start an assessment promptly if you have reasonable grounds to suspect an eligible breach and need more facts. Effective remedial action and other exceptions can change who needs notice or remove the notification duty altogether.
Check Scheme Coverage and the Trigger for Assessment
Name the legal entity that held the client information. Record who controlled the file, where it was stored and which parties could access it. A brokerage, aggregator and lender may each hold the same information, so check each entity’s role even if only one sent the email or ran the system.
Part IIIC of the Privacy Act 1988 sets out the Notifiable Data Breaches (NDB) scheme. It covers Australian Government agencies and businesses or not-for-profits with annual turnover above $3 million, as well as some entities below that threshold.
Check for small-business exceptions such as trading in personal information. Credit reporting bodies and credit providers have duties for covered credit information. A tax file number (TFN) recipient has duties for TFN information.
Check the OAIC’s guide to which entities the Privacy Act covers if coverage is unclear.
Record which information was exposed and what first gave you grounds for concern. For instance, a message delivery record can show that a client pack went to an unintended address while leaving open what the recipient could access.
The scheme requires an assessment when reasonable grounds for suspicion exist and the facts fall short of reasonable grounds for belief. The notification duty starts once the evidence gives you reasonable grounds to believe an eligible breach occurred, subject to any applicable exception.
Separately, check the brokerage’s lender and aggregator agreements. A contract can require notice of a suspected incident before you reach a view on statutory coverage or serious harm.
Assess Access, Disclosure, Loss and Serious Harm
Section 26WE applies to unauthorised access or disclosure where serious harm is likely. Ask whether a reasonable person would conclude that at least one person whose information was involved is likely to suffer serious harm. Access and disclosure are distinct: sending a readable attachment outside authorised channels can be a disclosure even if your records leave it unclear whether the recipient opened it.
For lost information, assess whether unauthorised access or disclosure is likely to occur. Then ask whether serious harm is likely if that access or disclosure occurs. The OAIC explains that likely means more probable than not in its guidance on identifying an eligible data breach.
Use the information available to a reasonable person in your brokerage’s position. Section 26WG directs you to consider the kinds and sensitivity of the information, the people who obtained it or could obtain it and the harm it could cause. Check how long it was exposed, which protections were in place, whether those protections could be defeated and whether a person intending to cause harm could make protected information readable.
Consider serious financial, physical, psychological, emotional or reputational harm to individuals.
Consider a hypothetical brokerage that emails the wrong person a link to a mortgage pack containing a couple’s driver licences, payslips and bank statements. Suppose verified logs show the unintended recipient downloaded the pack and the brokerage finds evidence of further sharing. The combined identity and income records could be used for identity fraud.
If the evidence makes that harm likely and the brokerage cannot reduce the risk in time, it has grounds to treat the incident as eligible.
Suppose instead that the recipient opened the pack through a controlled viewer and immediately contacted the brokerage. The brokerage revoked access before any harm occurred, verified the viewer prevented downloads and checked logs against the time the recipient could view the file.
Those facts could support a finding that serious harm is no longer likely if the assessor accounts for any details the recipient could still have copied or kept. Incomplete logs or uncertainty about further copies can change that finding.
Evaluate Remedial Action and Record the Finding
Section 26WF can remove the notification duty for an access or disclosure. The brokerage must act before serious harm occurs and its action must make serious harm unlikely for everyone affected, judged from a reasonable person’s position.
The duty to notify a particular person can fall away if the brokerage acts before the access or disclosure causes them serious harm. A reasonable person must conclude that the action makes serious harm unlikely for that person. The remaining notification duties continue.
For lost information, the exception also covers action that prevents unauthorised access or disclosure from occurring in the first place.
Check what your action actually stopped. The recipient’s assurance or deletion of the message may leave copies in downloads or forwarded email. Where available, preserve delivery and access logs, permission changes and independent confirmation of what the recipient accessed or retained.
Record any limits on that evidence before drawing your conclusion.
Section 26WH requires a reasonable and expeditious assessment. Take all reasonable steps to finish within 30 calendar days after the day the brokerage became aware of the grounds for suspicion. For example, if those grounds came to light on a Monday, Tuesday is day one.
Record why any part of the assessment runs beyond that period and the steps taken to finish it promptly.
Keep one decision record that the next person on the incident can use.
- Enter the incident reference, legal entity, coverage basis and time the grounds for suspicion became known.
- Record the affected people or groups and the kinds of information held about each. Identify who could access the information and which records support that finding.
- Describe the harm a reasonable person would expect and why it is or is not likely. Record what remedial action changed for each group, with supporting evidence.
- Name the assessor and decision-maker. Give each unresolved fact an owner and an escalation time.
- Record the finding for each affected group and the reason for each statutory or contractual notification decision.
Prepare Required Notifications
Once you have reasonable grounds to believe an eligible data breach occurred, prepare a statement unless an exception applies. Give it to the Australian Information Commissioner as soon as practicable.
Use the online Notifiable Data Breach form on the OAIC’s reporting page. The OAIC asks you to include details about containment and remedial action and attach a copy of the notification template for affected individuals.
Under section 26WK, the statement must identify the entity and give its contact details. Describe what happened and the kinds of information involved, then recommend specific steps people can take.
For exposed driver licence details, advise clients to ask the licence issuer about their options. If financial records were exposed, suggest they check their credit reports for applications they did not make. The OAIC’s advice for people who receive a breach notice sets out protective steps by information type.
Under section 26WL, take reasonable steps to tell people the contents of the statement as soon as practicable after preparing it. If practicable, you can notify everyone whose information was involved or notify the identified people at risk of serious harm. If neither option is practicable, publish the statement on the entity’s website if it has one and take reasonable steps to publicise the contents.
Where more than one entity has the same eligible breach, agree who will send the notices and retain evidence that the other entity complied with the relevant duties.
Under section 26WN, an enforcement body can withhold notice to individuals if its chief executive has reasonable grounds to believe notification would likely prejudice an enforcement activity. The statement still goes to the Commissioner, and it can omit the protective steps normally recommended for affected people.
Under section 26WP, check whether giving the Commissioner a copy of the statement or notifying individuals would conflict with a Commonwealth secrecy provision. The corresponding duty is limited to the extent of the conflict. If the regulations specify the secrecy provision, the corresponding duty falls away for that statement.
Under section 26WQ, the Commissioner can issue a written declaration waiving both duties or extending the time to notify individuals. Section 26WD excludes breaches already notified or required to be notified under section 75 of the My Health Records Act 2012.
Assign a separate owner for lender or aggregator notices. Record each agreement’s trigger, deadline, required content and contact method. Keep a copy of what went out and when.
Close the Assessment and Keep the Evidence
Confirm the decision record explains the coverage and harm findings and links to the underlying evidence. Keep the rationale even if no statutory notice was due. Record which people were notified, the basis for that scope and who owns any outstanding protective action.
Get prompt specialist privacy legal advice if the notification decision turns on disputed control of records, a secrecy provision or unresolved evidence of serious harm. While that advice is pending, keep collecting the evidence and assign someone to track the assessment and notification duties. Give that person authority to reopen the decision if new evidence changes the risk to clients.