Skip to main content

Broker guide

Sham Contracting: What Brokerages Must Know

Learn what sham contracting is, how the employee or contractor test works since 2024, and how brokerages set up contract brokers and processors safely.

Published
Updated

Sham contracting is when a business presents an employee as an independent contractor without a reasonable basis for doing so. For a brokerage hiring a broker or processor, the first check is who will control the work and whose business the worker will be building.

What is Sham Contracting?

The Fair Work Act 2009 prohibits representing an employment agreement as an independent contracting arrangement. An employer has a defence to that breach if it proves it reasonably believed the agreement was for independent services when it made the representation.

The Act also prohibits dismissing or threatening to dismiss an employee to re-engage them as a contractor for the same or substantially the same work. It separately prohibits knowingly making a false statement to persuade a current or former employee to do that work as a contractor.

Employee or Contractor: How the Test Works

Since the Fair Work Act changed in 2024, a constitutionally covered business, such as a trading company, generally uses the whole of relationship test. It takes both the agreed terms and how the parties work in practice into account. A contract headed “Independent Contractor” cannot decide the result.

A different test can apply to state-referred businesses, to work performed before the 2024 change or where an eligible high-income worker has opted out. If you’re reviewing an old arrangement, check which test applies to each period of work.

What to checkPoints towards employmentPoints towards independent contracting
Control over the workThe brokerage dictates hours and how to do the workThe worker chooses how and when to deliver the agreed services
Place in the businessThe worker is rostered and supervised as part of the brokerage teamThe worker runs a separate business and provides a service to the brokerage
Profit and lossThe brokerage bears the cost of fixing errorsThe worker can make a profit on an agreed fee and bears the cost of rework
Tools and systemsThe brokerage supplies the equipment and software for the jobThe worker pays for the equipment and software their business needs
DelegationThe brokerage requires the named person to do the workThe worker can engage and pay a suitably qualified substitute, subject to access and licensing requirements

Weigh the factors together. An Australian Business Number or an invoice tells you how the worker bills. The full working arrangement determines employment status under this test.

Make a separate assessment for tax, superannuation and state payroll tax. For an individual’s tax classification, the Australian Taxation Office (ATO) looks at the legal rights and obligations the parties agreed to.

A person can qualify as an employee for super even as an independent contractor, including under certain contracts mainly for their personal labour. State contractor provisions can treat payments as wages for payroll tax even when the person is genuinely self-employed.

Contract Brokers, Credit Representatives and Processors

A credit representative has permission to carry out specified credit activities under a credit licensee’s licence. The Australian Securities and Investments Commission (ASIC) explains the scope of authorisation. Assess the same broker’s employment status separately under the applicable worker test.

Contract Broker Under the Brokerage’s Brand

In a fictional brokerage, the owner assigns every lead, sets the broker’s hours and requires the broker to follow a manager’s daily instructions. Those facts point towards employment, even if the worker earns commission. A broker who brings their own clients, pays their own operating costs and chooses which work to accept has facts pointing towards independent contracting.

Outsourced Loan Processor

Suppose a processor quotes per file, serves several brokerages and corrects errors at their own expense. Those facts point towards independent contracting. A processor rostered on the operations team, taking daily assignments and required to do the work personally, has facts pointing towards employment.

Offshore Assistant

Suppose a brokerage directly hires someone abroad for set shifts and supervises them as a member of its admin team. Those facts point towards employment. A provider that agrees to deliver a defined admin service and chooses its own staffing has facts pointing towards independent contracting.

Where the person works and where the parties made the agreement can affect which laws apply. The Fair Work Ombudsman’s guidance on overseas work explains when Australian employment standards can reach an employee working overseas.

Terms to Check in the Agreement

  • Record who sets working hours and targets. Check whether the agreement buys coverage during a shift or a defined result.
  • Identify who brings in leads and who controls the relationship with those clients.
  • List whose systems and equipment the worker uses. Identify access required by privacy or credit obligations separately from day-to-day control of the work.
  • Check whether the worker can decline work or take other clients. If delegation is allowed, check how they can engage and pay someone else to do the work.

Penalties and the Cost of Getting It Wrong

A brokerage can face civil penalties for sham contracting. If it treated an employee as a contractor, it can also owe back pay and applicable leave entitlements. The Banking, Finance and Insurance Award may apply, depending on the duties and award coverage.

A missed super contribution can trigger the superannuation guarantee charge. That exposure can arise on a contractor arrangement that falls within the super rules.

Assess payroll tax in the relevant state. For example, Revenue NSW’s contractor rules treat the taxable part of payments under a relevant contract as wages if no exemption applies.

How to Set Up Contractor Arrangements

Decide how the role will operate before you choose an agreement. Use this checklist before someone starts and again when the job changes.

  1. Define the role. Write down the work, who directs it and who bears the cost of mistakes. Assess employment status, tax, super and payroll tax under their respective rules.
  2. Make the agreement match the work. Put the actual terms for payment, supervision and delegation in writing. If the role is employment, set it up on payroll and check the applicable pay and conditions.
  3. Review the arrangement when it changes. A processor who starts on occasional files and later joins a fixed roster is a reason to reassess. Compare the agreement with actual instructions, invoices and rosters.

Get employment law advice before signing if the facts point in different directions, before switching an employee to contracting or before engaging someone whose work spans jurisdictions. If an existing arrangement looks misclassified, bring the agreement, payment records and work instructions to the adviser so they can assess the past period as well as the proposed terms.

Bring policy research and scenario planning together

Ask lender policy questions, plan client scenarios and compare lenders in one conversation, with the policy wording behind each answer.
See how it works14 days free · No credit card